Bilingual intake for South Florida law firms

REVIEWS · BAR RULES

Asking for reviews under the Bar rules

A Google review from a real client helps the next person pick a firm. Asking for one is fine. How the firm asks, when, and what it offers are where the Florida Bar rules come in. So is the reply when a review is bad. Here is each part, in order.

By Aday Interactive, Inc., Coral Gables. We build LegalCRM.pro; we are not attorneys.
A man sits at an outdoor cafe table in Coral Gables, reading something on his phone and smiling slightly, with a coffee in front of him.

We are not attorneys and this is not legal advice. It points to the rules on asking for reviews and answering them. That way your firm knows what to ask its Bar counsel.

THE SHORT ANSWER

Ask after the matter closes, once, in plain words, with a link. Do not write the review, suggest what it should say, or give anything in exchange (Rule 4-7.17(b)). If the firm reuses a review on its website or in an ad, it is a testimonial. Rule 4-7.13(b)(9) sets the terms for that. When a review is bad, reply without revealing anything about the client’s matter (Rule 4-1.6(a); Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 20-1).

When to ask

After the matter closes. While the case is open, the client depends on the firm. A request can feel like a condition of good service. After the close, the client can judge the whole experience. Saying no costs them nothing.

Ask every closed client the same way. Asking only the happy ones bends the picture. It also matters later. The firm may put reviews on its own site. If it does, the rule asks that a testimonial reflect what the firm’s clients generally experience (Rule 4-7.13(b)(9)(C)).

What the ask may say

Short, honest, and easy to ignore. For example:

Example only. “Hi [Name], this is [Firm] in Coral Gables. Your matter is now closed. If you are willing, a Google review helps other people find us. Here is the link: [link]. Thank you either way. Reply STOP to opt out.”

  • Name the firm. The client should know who is asking.
  • Ask once, remind once at most. Then stop. A reply or STOP ends it.
  • Do not suggest the words or the stars. A testimonial the lawyer wrote or drafted is barred (Rule 4-7.13(b)(9)(D)). A sample review for the client to copy is drafting it.
  • Do not ask them to mention the result. A review about a result brings its own disclaimer duty if the firm ever reuses it. It can also reveal more about the matter than the client meant to.
  • Same message in both languages. A client who worked with the firm in Spanish gets the ask in Spanish, saying the same thing.

Nothing of value in exchange

Rule 4-7.17(b) says a lawyer may not give anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer’s services. The exceptions are things like the reasonable cost of ads the rules allow. The usual charges of a lawyer referral service are another. A review is a recommendation. And a testimonial given in exchange for something of value is on the list of deceptive ads in Rule 4-7.13(b)(9)(E).

So no gift card, no discount on the final bill, no raffle entry, and no donation per review. A thank-you note is fine. If someone at the firm wants a thank-you gift program of any kind, have counsel look at it first.

When the firm reuses a review

Whether a review that sits on Google is the firm’s own advertising is a question for counsel. The firm may copy it onto its website, a social post, or an ad. Once it does, it is a testimonial in the firm’s advertising. Rule 4-7.13(b)(9) treats a testimonial as deceptive if:

  • the person is not qualified to judge what they are praising,
  • it is not the person’s actual experience,
  • it does not represent what the firm’s clients generally experience,
  • the lawyer wrote or drafted it,
  • the person got something of value for it, or
  • it lacks the disclaimer that a prospective client may not obtain the same or similar results.

The comment to the rule says clients are well placed to speak to courtesy, promptness, efficiency, and professional demeanor. The Bar’s ad handbook adds a point. To use a testimonial about the client’s matter, the firm needs the client’s informed consent (Rule 4-1.6(a)). The rule text and the handbook word the disclaimer a little differently. So have counsel confirm the current text.

Answering a bad review

Rule 4-1.6(a) says a lawyer must not reveal information relating to a client’s representation. The client’s informed consent, or a narrow exception, is needed first. Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 20-1 applies that to online reviews. A lawyer may not reveal confidential information in reply to a former client’s bad review. That holds even if it is in the public record. The reply has to stay general. Ethics Opinion 21-1 covers reviews from people who were never clients. If accurate, the lawyer may say the person is not a client or former client.

Example only. “We see this review and we disagree with it. Our duties to clients keep us from discussing any matter here.” No dates, no facts, no “as the court record shows.” The attorney approves every reply. No automated system or staff member posts one on its own.

Where LegalCRM.pro fits

On the Practice and Group plans, LegalCRM.pro can send the review ask when a matter moves to closed. It does so where your firm has decided that is right. Every closed client gets the same message and no one has to remember. It is set up as one ask and, if the firm wants, one reminder. It stops on a reply or on STOP, ALTO, or PARE. It holds scheduled texts from 8 PM to 8 AM, the hours in Fla. Stat. 501.616(6). It never drafts a review. It offers nothing for one, and it never answers a review. When we build it for you, we write every message to fit Chapter 4-7 and the ABA Model Rules. Your attorney reviews and approves all of it before we turn anything on. Anything your firm writes or changes later, it reviews against the same rules.

Each rule, with its ABA counterpart and what stays the firm’s, is on the Advertising Compliance page.

Related

See the review ask your attorney would approve

A 30-minute demo shows the closed-matter message, the optional reminder, and where it stops. It runs in English and Spanish.